FREE DELIVERY ON EVERY ORDER

Olive Oil Labels Explained: Extra Virgin, Cold Pressed, First Press and More


Olive oil labels are full of words that sound reassuring: extra virgin, cold pressed, first press, pure, light. Some are strictly regulated. Others mean very little. Here's how to tell them apart.

The grades

  • Extra virgin olive oil: the top grade. Made only by mechanical means, with no chemicals or refining, and it must pass both laboratory tests (including free acidity of 0.8% or less) and a professional tasting panel that finds no faults. See how to read an olive oil lab report.
  • Virgin olive oil: also unrefined, but allowed small taste faults and acidity up to 2%.
  • "Olive oil" (sometimes "pure" or "classic"): mostly refined olive oil with some virgin oil added for flavour.
  • "Light" olive oil: refined oil that's light in flavour and colour, not in calories.
  • Olive pomace oil: extracted with solvents from the paste left after pressing, then refined.

"Cold pressed", "cold extracted" and "first press"

These are the most misunderstood words on the label.

In the EU, two terms are regulated:

  • "Cold extraction" may be used when the oil is obtained below 27°C, by percolation or centrifugation, the way almost all modern mills work.
  • "First cold pressing" may only be used when the oil is obtained below 27°C using a traditional hydraulic press.

Keeping temperatures low preserves aroma and polyphenols. But "first press" on its own means little today. Modern mills extract oil in a single continuous process, so there's no second pressing to compare it with. Every extra virgin oil from a modern mill is, in effect, a first press.

Harvest date vs best-before date

The best-before date is usually set from bottling, not harvest, so it tells you little about freshness. Look for a harvest date or harvest year. In the northern hemisphere, the freshest oil in winter will say this year's harvest. More in how to tell if olive oil is fresh.

Origin: "Product of Italy" vs "packed in Italy"

EU law requires virgin and extra virgin olive oils to state their origin. Read the wording carefully:

  • "Product of Italy" / "100% Italian olive oil": olives grown and pressed in Italy.
  • "Blend of EU oils" or "EU and non-EU oils": oil from several countries, often blended for price.
  • "Packed in", "bottled in" or "imported from" Italy says where it was bottled, not where the olives grew.

DOP / PDO and IGP / PGI

A DOP (in English, PDO, Protected Designation of Origin) means the olives were grown, pressed and bottled in a defined area, from set varieties, under extra controls. An IGP (PGI) is looser: at least one stage happened in the named area. Both are useful signs, but plenty of excellent oils, including many single-estate oils, aren't certified under either.

Organic

Certified organic oil in the EU carries the green EU leaf logo and a certifier's code, such as IT-BIO-000, telling you who inspected it. It means no synthetic pesticides or fertilisers were used in the grove.

Single estate and single variety

"Single estate" means one producer's own olives; "monovarietal" or "single variety" means one type of olive. Neither is regulated as tightly as the grades, but both tell you the oil wasn't blended from many sources.

How our label reads

  • Grade: extra virgin olive oil.
  • Origin: Italy, from our own estate near Vescia, Umbria.
  • Variety: 100% Moraiolo.
  • Extraction: cold extraction, below 27°C, in a modern continuous mill.
  • Organic: certified by CCPB.
  • Harvest: 2026, first milled 5 October 2026.

See the 2026 harvest →